How they feel

Maui is the island of choices. The tourism office splits it into five areas and names Wailea and Kihei for oceanside hotels, Kaanapali for resorts and sunsets, and Lahaina for charming stays. Add the Haleakala summit, which can be about 30 F cooler than the coast, and the Road to Hana, and a week fills easily. Start with things to do in Maui.

Kauai, nicknamed the Garden Island, is the fourth-largest Hawaiian island and is known for tropical forests, waterfalls and beaches. Its tourism page lists kayaking on the Wailua River, Opaekaa Falls, Wailua Falls, snorkeling at Poipu Beach, Spouting Horn, Waimea Canyon and Kokee State Park, and helicopter tours over the Napali Coast. See things to do in Kauai.

Conditions to check before you commit

Kauai's tourism page says most businesses are operating normally after Hurricane Lowell, though some may have limited staffing, and points to openkauai.org for open businesses. The Hawaii State Parks notices on 7 November 2026 still showed Kauai state parks under closure (see Opaekaa Falls), so confirm the specific park before you plan a day around it. Maui's page asks you to check for temporary maintenance closures at Iao Valley, where non-residents pay $5 per car for parking.

Hiking compared

On Maui, the National Park Service lists the Sliding Sands trail into Haleakala crater as strenuous (the first overlook is 0.5 mile round trip, the full crossing to Halemau'u is 11 miles), the Halemau'u viewpoint hike at 2.2 miles round trip, and the Pipiwai Trail in the Kipahulu district at 4 miles round trip, moderately strenuous. Details are in best hikes on Maui. On Kauai, see Waimea Canyon and Opaekaa Falls.

Which one for whom

  • Resort week with choice of areas: Maui.
  • Waterfalls, canyon and coast from the air: Kauai, where the tourism office lists helicopter tours over the Napali Coast. See Kauai helicopter tours.
  • Honeymoon: both work; see Hawaii honeymoon.
  • Winter swimming: Maui's south side; Kauai's winter waves are bigger, per the tourism office.
  • Summer: Kauai's ocean is calmer in summer, the tourism office says.

Both islands in one trip

There is no direct bridge: you fly. See Hawaii island hopping. Choose one island if you have under a week.

Hotels

The link in the box below searches Maui hotels on Booking.com. For Kauai, see where to stay in Kauai; for Maui, where to stay in Maui.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Booking Kauai park-based plans without checking the state-parks closure notice.
  • Treating the Haleakala sunrise as a casual stop: it needs a $1 vehicle reservation for entry between 3:00 am and 7:00 am, booked on recreation.gov up to 60 days ahead.
  • Expecting the same sea conditions on both islands in winter: the tourism office says Kauai has bigger waves then.
  • Flying into Kauai without a plan for the connection: the tourism office says many travelers connect through Honolulu.

FAQ

Is Maui or Kauai better for a first visit?

Maui offers more resort areas; Kauai offers a quieter, greener setting. First-timers who want choice usually find Maui easier.

Which has better weather?

Both follow the same two seasons. The state names April, May, September and October for Maui, and summer for calmer Kauai seas.

Is Kauai open after Hurricane Lowell?

The tourism page says most businesses are operating normally, some with limited staffing. Check openkauai.org and the state parks notices for the places you want.

Where do I fly into?

Kahului (OGG) for Maui and Lihue (LIH) for Kauai.

Can I do both in a week?

You can, with a flight between islands, but the time lost in transit is the main cost.

Oahu is compared with Maui in Oahu vs Maui.

Hawaii Authority editorial team, 7 November 2026.